ELECTION

Obama Can Break GOP Obstruction and Appoint Garland to Supreme Court

obama-bourbon

The Washington Post recently broke a story that outlined the conditions, as specified in the Constitution, that would allow the President to bypass the Senate and appoint Federal Judge Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court – and they show already-set precedent.

The article was penned by Gregory L. Diskant, a well-respected and experienced attorney who sits on the national governing Board of Common Cause. He points out examples in from the mid-twentieth century where Senate hearings for Supreme Court nominees were swift and easy, and explains that what the Republicans are doing through exerting an unprecedented amount of obstruction is a symptom of a broken system, spiraling out of control.

In the mire and muck of refusing to confirm Merrick Garland, Diskant highlights another problem: “Meanwhile, dozens of nominations to federal judgeships and executive offices are pending before the Senate, many for more than a year. Our system prides itself on its checks and balances, but there seems to be no balance to the Senate’s refusal to perform its constitutional duty.” To translate, there is a huge, constantly building back log of confirmations that is putting an unnecessary and dangerous pressure on our judicial system. Eventually, the bend could break.

Diskant points out the possibilities, however, that are already contained in the Constitution should a problem such as ours today arise.  He reminds us of the particular wording of the Constitution, that the Presdient “shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint . . . Judges of the supreme Court, and all other Officers of the United States.” Note that the president has two powers: the power to “nominate” and the separate power to “appoint.” In between the nomination and the appointment, the president must seek the “Advice and Consent of the Senate.” What does that mean, and what happens when the Senate does nothing?”

So the Senate may reserve the right to consent through a majority vote, but what about circumstances when Congress is clearly shirking its responsibility? Diskant argues that failure to provide advice and consent is, in effect, a waiver of their right to do so, and would allow President Obama the right and privilege to appoint his choice regardless. He gives an example of precedent that was already set by our Supreme Court, “ ‘No procedural principle is more familiar to this Court than that a constitutional right,’ or a right of any other sort, ‘may be forfeited in criminal as well as civil cases by the failure to make timely assertion of the right before a tribunal having jurisdiction to determine it.’ ”

Finally, Diskant gives us a picture of what that might look like. “Presumably the Senate would then bring suit challenging the appointment. This should not be viewed as a constitutional crisis but rather as a healthy dispute between the president and the Senate about the meaning of the Constitution. This kind of thing has happened before. In 1932, the Supreme Court ruled that the Senate did not have the power to rescind a confirmation vote after the nominee had already taken office. More recently, the court determined that recess appointments by the president were no longer proper because the Senate no longer took recesses.”

Wow. This is HUGE news! If you think President Obama should put an end to this unprecedented example of Republican obstructionism, then Share this Article on FACEBOOK! Let America know!


Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Popular

Your source for news, stories, and events. YOUR politics, YOUR perspective. The PROUD Liberal.

Copyright © 2015 The Mag Theme. Theme by MVP Themes, powered by Wordpress.

To Top