We’ve decided to Fact Check Donald Trump from Wednesday night’s third and (mercifully) last presidential debate between Trump and Democratic opponent Hillary Clinton. This can be a daunting task, as Donald Trump and facts are something like oil and water, but here are a few of the biggest Trump whoppers from the debate:
FACT CHECK #1 – Donald Trump said Hillary Clinton is going to get rid of the Second Amendment
FALSE
Trump has repeated this claim throughout the campaign, mostly to stir up fear and anger in his gun toting constituency, despite the fact that this claim is ridiculous and has been debunked over and over again.
During the debate, Trump again said that Clinton “would take away our guns,” and his campaign tweeted that the 2nd Amendment wouldn’t “Survive a Clinton presidency.” In reality, Clinton has never said any such thing, and none of her policy would even remotely hurt the 2nd Amendment, just as claims of Obama “taking away our guns” have been white noise.
Trump himself, quite ironically, has repeatedly backed new gun control measures in the past. Last month he suggested that law enforcement should simply “take the guns away” when they find them on American citizens. This is the very government gun-grabbing that is one of his favorite straw man arguments whenever Democrats propose the simplest of gun regulations. No Democratic politician has ever proposed such blatant gun confiscation but its no problem for Donald Trump, at least when the gun-owners are African-Americans.
FACT CHECK #2 -Donald Trump said ISIS Leader Left Mosul Due to Our Military’s Ineptitude
During the debate, Trump insulted the U.S. Military action against ISIS in Iraq by claiming that we can’t “sneak attack” them because they left the city of Mosul after we told them we were coming. Aside from the laughable notion that we sneak attack enemies like in some action movie, the claim was just blatantly false. According to Kurdish official and former Iraqi minister of finance Hoshyar Zebari, Kurdish intelligence indicates that Daeshi caliph Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi and military commander Fawzi Aliis are still in Mosul. Of course Trump is incapable of conceiving of a leader who wouldn’t instantly abandon his men to preserve his own skin, which says a lot about Trump would act as leader of the U.S. military.
FALSE
Trump towers were absolutely built by undocumented Polish workers. Clinton zinged Trump on his incredibly hypocritical record of illegal immigrants working for him, but she wasn’t the first. Marco Rubio brought it up as well during one of the Republican primary debates.
This is according to the Daily Beast report:
The 200 demolition workers—nicknamed the Polish Brigade because of their home country—worked 12-hour shifts, seven days a week with no overtime to knock down the old Bonwit Teller building and make room for Trump Tower on Fifth Avenue in Manhattan.
According to testimony in a protracted civil suit in federal court, the laborers were paid $5 an hour or less when they were paid at all. Some went unpaid after the contractor had financial troubles. A few never received even the paltry sum that was owed them for their dirty and hazardous efforts preceding the construction of Trump’s monument to his own wealth.
“They were undocumented and worked ‘off the books,’” Manhattan federal Judge Charles Stewart said of the workers after they became the subject of a 1983 lawsuit. “No records were kept, no Social Security or other taxes were withheld.”
Donald Trump built his “empire” on the backs of low paid and unpaid migrant workers. His pledges to keep them out of the country as president are laughably hypocritical.
FACT CHECK #4 –Donald Trump said he doesn’t know Vladimir Putin
This is one is an utterly laughable debate claim by Trump. Not only does he know the Russian President, he’s good friends with him. Here is video of Trump saying nearly the exact opposite about his relationship with Putin: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dn1ZK2kcfQ8
In that video, Trump repeatedly and emphatically says “I do have a relationship with Vladimir Putin” before praising the Russian strongman’s record as president.
FACT CHECK #5 -Donald Trump said The Supreme Court Justices I Will Appoint Will Be Pro-Life
MIXED TRUTH
While it’s impossible to predict the justices he would actually appoint were he elected president, they would likely be pro-choice. During his time as presidential candidate, Trump has been a vocal opponent of a woman’s right to choose. This was not always the case though.“I’m very pro-choice,” Trump said in that 1999 interview. “I hate the concept of abortion. … But still, I just believe in choice.”
During this campaign, though, Trump has turned drastically from that position he took in 1999, even going as far as to claim that women who have abortions should be subject to “some sort of punishment.”
FALSE
Trump asserted that abortions can take place just one day before birth. This doesn’t really happen.Most abortions take place early in the pregnancy. One-third take place at six weeks of pregnancy or earlier; 89 percent occur in the first 12 weeks, according to the Guttmacher Institute, which supports abortion rights. Only 1.2 percent of abortions — about 12,000 a year — take place after 21 weeks. (The Supreme Court has held that states may not prohibit abortions “necessary to preserve the life or health” of the mother.)On top of that, Guttmacher says that 43 states already prohibit some abortions after a certain point in pregnancy, such as fetal viability, in the third trimester or after a certain number of weeks. So this is already a rare procedure that is prohibited in much of the country. In fact, there are only four doctors left in the United States who are even willing to perform third trimester abortions.
FACT CHECK #7 – Donald Trump said $6 Billion was stolen or lost from the State Dept. when Hillary Clinton was Sec. of State.
FALSE
The Washington Post has already debunked this Trump claim several times, and again last night after he repeated it at the debate:
We had previously given Trump Four Pinocchios for this false claim, apparently aimed at rebutting news stories about the nearly $1 billion loss that he claimed in a 1995 tax return that was made public by the New York Times.
Trump misunderstands a $6 billion figure that appeared in a 2014 management alert from the State Department Inspector General. The alert summarized a variety of recent audits that indicated paperwork deficiencies in closing out contracts that were issued in Iraq, Afghanistan and Africa. But no money is missing or lost, a point that the IG emphasized in a letter to The Washington Post in 2014. Instead, the alert highlighted missing paperwork, not dollars.
Trump is also wrong to blame Clinton. We examined the audit reports referenced in alert and concluded that easily two-thirds, or perhaps more, concerned contracts that predated Clinton’s tenure at State.
FACT CHECK #8 -Donald Trump said Hillary Clinton criminally destroyed 33,000 emails after getting a subpoena from the United States Congress.
MOSTLY FALSE
Clinton did delete thousands of emails. That is well-established. The “criminally” part is untrue, as has been proven time and time again. Also, Trump is misleading the public when he implies that Clinton deleted the emails after she got the subpoena.
Politifact has this handy timeline of the email scandal that proves Trump’s statements mostly false.